The Women and Equalities Committee has called for UK women to have protections similar to those in Germany after a ‘shocking’ increase in workplace pregnancy discrimination over the past decade.
MPs demand urgent action, calling on the Government to publish an ambitious, detailed plan within the next two years or risk a further rise in pregnant women being forced out of their work.
Recommendations include changes to health and safety practices, preventing discriminatory redundancies and an increase in protection for casual, agency and zero-hours workers.
Committee Chair Maria Miller commented: “The arrival of a new baby puts family finances under extreme pressure yet, despite this, thousands of expectant and new mothers have no choice but to leave their work because of concerns about the safety of their child or pregnancy discrimination. Shockingly this figure has almost doubled in the last decade, now standing at 54,000.”
"There are now record numbers of women in work in the UK. The economy will suffer unless employers modernise their workplace practices to ensure effective support and protection for expectant and new mums.”
"The Government’s approach has lacked urgency and bite. It needs to set out a detailed plan outlining the specific actions it will take to tackle this unacceptable level of discrimination. This work must be underpinned by concrete targets and changes to laws and protections to increase compliance by employers to improve women’s lives.”
Increased protection from redundancy
Research carried out by the Department for Business, Innovation and Skills (BIS) and the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) revealed that pregnant women and mothers now face more discrimination at work than they did a decade ago. 11% of women reported being either dismissed, made compulsorily redundant when others in their workplace were not, or treated so poorly they felt they had to leave their job. The Committee’s report urges the Government to change the law to give new and expectant mothers additional protection from redundancy. It recommends implementation of a system similar to that used in Germany under which such women can be made redundant only in specified circumstances.
Maria Miller commented:“It is difficult to accept the EHRC and Government’s characterisation of this as merely about enforcement and we are persuaded by the evidence that additional protections against discriminatory redundancies are needed.”
Tribunals and access to justice
During their inquiry MPs heard strong evidence that women were not taking action in large enough numbers to ensure compliance from employers on existing protections. Witnesses argued that the three month time limit on pregnancy and maternity discrimination cases did not recognise the pressures on expectant mothers and the report recommends that the time limit is extended to six months. The Committee also recommends a substantial reduction in tribunal fees for discrimination cases.
Maria Miller commented: “The Government’s approach to improving compliance with pregnancy and maternity discrimination law has been confusing. It has stated that it is important to focus on enforcement and yet its main policy focus is awareness-raising and persuasion. It has voiced concern about the low numbers of women taking enforcement action against their employer, but has rejected the EHRC’s recommendations to remove unfair barriers to justice and has no plans to ease the burden of enforcement on women.
We agree that it is preferable for workplace disputes to be resolved at the earliest possible stage and that tribunals should be a last resort. However we also recognise the important role that tribunals play in enabling individuals to seek redress, in holding employers to account, and as a wider deterrent.”
Extending maternity-related rights to casual, agency and zero hours workers
The Committee also heard evidence that there is a clear need for new and expectant mothers who are casual, agency and zero-hours workers to be properly protected. The Committee found that women in this group are more likely to report a risk or impact to their health and welfare than other types of worker; more likely to leave their employer as a result of health and safety risks not being resolved; and less likely to feel confident about challenging discriminatory behaviour.
Maria Miller commented: “We heard concerning evidence about the experiences of pregnant casual, agency and zero hours workers. While we understand the reason they do not have the same day one rights as employees, employers should not be able to avoid affording regular, long-term workers the same basic rights as employees because they have a different contract type.”
The Committee recommends that paid time off for antenatal appointments is extended to all workers after a short qualifying period and that the Government urgently review the pregnancy and maternity-related rights available to casual, agency and zero-hours workers.
Other recommendations made by the committee include:
• Employers should be required to undertake an individual risk assessment when they are informed that a woman who works for them is pregnant, has given birth in the past six months or is breastfeeding. The Health and Safety Executive should include this requirement in its guidance to employers by the end of 2016;
• New and expectant mothers who are concerned that their health and/or the health of their baby is being put at risk by their work should have an easily accessible, formal mechanism to compel their employer to deal with such risks appropriately
• Given the uncertainty about what Brexit will mean, a statement of the Government’s intention to ensure that rights and protections are not eroded would provide welcome reassurance during this period of transition;
• The Government should work with the main organisations providing free, good-quality, one-to-one advice to women on pregnancy and maternity discrimination to monitor the uptake of and estimated unmet need for such advice
Read full report here
IN THE PRESS
International Business Times UK - Aug 31, 2016
Women and equalities committee urges government to tackle issue of new mums forced to leave jobs.
BBC News - Aug 31, 2016
"Urgent action" is needed to give pregnant women and new mothers more protection at work after a "shocking" increase in discrimination, MPs say.
economia - Sep 1, 2016
MPs said the government needs to take “urgent action” and set out an “ambitious, detailed” plan within the next two years in a bid to stop a further rise in pregnant women and mothers being forced out of work.
Telegraph.co.uk - Aug 31, 2016
A report from the Women and Equalities Select Committee, chaired by Maria Miller, has called for new protections to stem the number of women being forced to leave their jobs illegally. Last year, the Equality and Human Rights Commission (EHRC) found ...
WebMD.Boots.com - Aug 31, 2016
An investigation by the House of Commons Women and Equalities Committee found that the problem has got worse over the last decade and calls for urgent action to stop pregnant women and mothers being forced out of the workplace.
Financial Times - Aug 30, 2016
Discrimination in the workplace against pregnant women and new mothers has risen sharply over the past decade to an “unacceptable level”, with a committee of MPs calling for tough new protections. A report commissioned last year by the government and ...
Grazia - Sep 1, 2016
In the past decade, the way in which pregnant women are treated in the workplace has come on leaps and bounds. That's right, isn't it? Wrong. Very wrong. Doubly wrong, in fact. The Lowdown on Pregnancy Discrimination. A parliamentary report released by ...
Training Journal - Aug 31, 2016
The CIPD has responded to the new report on pregnancy discrimination at work from the Women and Equalities Committee, calling the mistreatment of working mothers as "inexcusable." Working mum and child. The number of expectant mothers forced to ...
Huffington Post UK - Sep 1, 2016
There has been a lot around about discrimination against working mums over August. It's not just the Institute for Fiscal Studies study on the gender pay gap and this week's report from the Women and Equalities Committee. There has been research on ...
International Business Times UK - Sep 1, 2016
Working women having children is not new. Depressingly, it seems that discrimination by some employers and some workplaces towards mothers-to-be and those who have children is also not new and is getting worse. This week's report, by the House of ...
Huffington Post UK - Aug 30, 2016
Pregnant women need greater protections in the workplace to combat a “shocking” rise in discrimination in the last decade, a new report has found. MPs are calling for urgent action from the government to ensure there is not a further escalation in the ...
Management Today - Aug 31, 2016
So, pregnant women face more discrimination at work than they did a decade ago. Hardly a ringing endorsement of the much-hyped diversity agenda.
CIPD (blog) - Sep 1, 2016
A new parliamentary report is calling for better protection for pregnant workers, as the number of women leaving their jobs because of concerns about the safety of their child or pregnancy discrimination has reached 54,000 per year. The Women and ...
Fortune - Aug 31, 2016
The World's Most Powerful Women: September 1. A group of MPs laid into the U.K. government yesterday for the rising rate of discrimination related to pregnancy and maternity leave in the country. Conservative Maria Miller, chair of the Women and ...
The Bolton News - Aug 30, 2016
Urgent action is needed to give pregnant women and new mothers more protection at work, after research revealed a "shocking" increase in discrimination over the past 10 years, a parliamentary report has said. MPs on the House of Commons Women and ...
The Guardian - Aug 30, 2016
MPs are demanding urgent government action to tackle a “shocking and unacceptable” rise in workplace discrimination in the UK against expectant and new mothers over the last decade. A report published by the women and equalities select committee ...
Fortune - Aug 31, 2016
The government's current approach is lacking “urgency and bite,” said an MP. Last week there was a string of bad news for pregnant women and moms in the U.K. First, British charity Citizens Advice said women are increasingly concerned about ...
Bloomberg - Aug 30, 2016
Pregnant women and new mothers face growing discrimination at work in the U.K., with tens of thousands being forced out of their jobs every year, according to a panel of lawmakers that called on the government to adopt German-style protections. As many ...
Morning Star Online - Aug 30, 2016
BOSSES targeting mums-to-be “must feel the full force of the law,” Labour said yesterday as a new report revealed that pregnancy-related discrimination has doubled over the past 10 years. A committee of MPs called for a ban on employers making pregnant ...
Politics.co.uk - Aug 31, 2016
“The latest report from the Women and Equalities Commission sadly reflects and confirms the issues and concerns the NASUWT has been raising with Government and employers about the treatment of women teachers for some time. “The NASUWT's ...
Personnel Today - Aug 31, 2016
The Women and Equalities Committee has called for “urgent action” to stop discrimination against new and expectant mothers at work. In a select committee report released today, it has recommended that UK women have similar protections to women in ...
Training Journal - Aug 31, 2016
Urgent protections are needed to tackle the “shocking” discrimination against new and expectant mothers at work, MPs have said. Maternity leave directive. New and expectant mothers must be afforded better protections at work, MPs have said. Phioto ...
Closer - Aug 31, 2016
The Women and Equalities Committee has discovered that there is currently a shocking level of workplace pregnancy discrimination, which has rocketed over the past decade. The number of mums-to-be forced to leave work has doubled to 54,000 since 2005 ...
Sky News - Aug 30, 2016
MPs say rising numbers of new mothers are losing their jobs unfairly and Government plans to tackle discrimination "lack bite". 06:51, UK, Wednesday 31 August 2016. A pregnant woman. Video: Pregnancy Discrimination At Work On The Rise. Share on ...
Daily Mail - Aug 30, 2016
Urgent action is needed to give pregnant women and new mothers more protection at work, MPs said last night. Following a 'shocking' increase in discrimination over the past ten years, they called for firms to be banned from making women redundant when ...